Skip to main content

It’s better to be a jack of all sports

For parents of student-athletes, there’s one word from the announcers that makes their hearts swell with pride.

Goal!!! 

Sports can foster physical and mental growth in children, and seeing your child succeed in sports is a great feeling.  

However, due to the increasingly competitive nature of high school sports, some parents enroll kids in multiple teams or use private trainers so their kids can play one sport year-round. While single sport specialization sounds like a good way to increase your child’s skills, it may do more harm than good in the long run.

“Sport specialization has been a trend recently that aligns with the increasing competition in teen sports,” said Geisinger primary care sports medicine physician Justin Tunis, MD. “The problem with specialization is that your teen might overuse certain muscle groups, which can predispose to injury. Young athletes should take at least one season off from their main sport every year and be sure to rest at least one day every week.”

Overuse injuries
Sports-related injuries, especially minor ones, are very common. But kids who play a single sport year-round are at risk for long-term overuse injuries.

“Some examples of overuse injuries include conditions like tennis elbow, jumper’s knee, shin splints and little-league shoulder,” said Dr. Tunis. “These conditions come from overexertion and not giving yourself adequate time to recover. Most people think that to train for a sport, you have to practice all the time. In reality, rest and recovery are just as important as sport specific training.”

Overuse injuries come from damage to tendons, ligaments and muscles. Repetitive motions like swinging a tennis racket can lead to stress on certain body parts, which can lead to injury and inflammation. The best way to treat these injuries is with rest, but if the condition is too severe, it may require medical intervention to correct. 

Part of the reason that overuse injuries are common in teenagers is that they’re still growing. Excessive and repetitive use of muscles and joints during growth spurts can cause serious, sometimes permanent, damage. As a general rule of thumb, teens shouldn’t practice more hours than their age — if they’re 13, they shouldn’t practice more than 13 hours a week.

The American Academy of Pediatricians recommends that teens refrain from specializing in one sport until they’re at least 15 years old. 

If your child is showing symptoms of an overuse injury, ask them to stop playing and see your physician. 

Why your teen should play multiple sports
Consider this: In college, it’s not uncommon to be a multisport athlete. In fact, some of the best athletes play more than one sports. 

In a recent survey of NCAA athletes: 

  • 71 percent of Division I men’s football players were multisport athletes. 
  • 88 percent of Division I men’s and 83 percent of women’s lacrosse players played other sports.
  • 87 percent of Division I female runners and 91 percent of male runners were active in another sport.

“If your teen concentrates only on one sport, they may be at increased risk for injury,” said Dr. Tunis. “For muscles to grow, they need time to recover, and repeated use and abuse could possibly cause long-term harm. By playing multiple sports, especially ones that are very different, teens can develop different muscle groups, which can lead to increased overall athleticism.”

Obviously, avoiding a career-ending injury as a teen is a huge benefit to playing more than one sport. Another benefit of being a multisport athlete is the transfer of skills between sports. For a basketball player, swimming would be a good complementary sport—strengthening the legs will help with jumping. 

However, in some instances, teams will discourage athletes from joining other sports. There are coaches who will ask teens to sign contracts saying they won’t play any other sports. This can be harmful to your child, so it’s best to talk with the coaches and address your concerns. 

Primary care sports medicine physician Justin Tunis, MD, sees patients at Geisinger Orthopaedics and Sports Medicine Scranton, 3 West Olive St., Scranton. To schedule an appointment,  call 800-275-6401.

Soccer playing doing a drill

Get complete care for orthopaedic conditions